Episode Recaps, Season 8 »

SCOTT MACINTYRE Voted Off American Idol (Finally)

Published on: April 8, 2009 – 9:10 pm by Jillian Madison Comment

Anoop and Scott were the bottom two performers tonight, but ultimately Scott Macintyre was the one sent home. No surprise there. He sucked last night, and frankly, I have no idea how he even made it as far as he did in the competition. Bye, Scott. I won’t miss you one bit.

scott macintyre american idol

What else did we learn tonight? Flo-Rida sweats like a pig, Kellie Pickler still can’t sing live, and Adam Lambert looks perfectly at home with half of his face covered in glitter and plastic.

adam glambert american idol

We’ll see you next week for more WEHATEIDOL.




  1. Ricky
    April 8th, 2009

    awwwww. poor scott. NOT!!!!!!!!!! I cannot say that I am sorry that this talentless idiot is gone. Sure, were all sorry that hes blind, but he can’t sing. Point Blanc. Glad hes gone. Now we only have to get Adam Glambert and Danny “Overrated” Gokey to leave. Than I’ll be happy.

  2. my2cents
    April 8th, 2009

    kellie pickler should have been voted off. she was worse than scott.

  3. Ricky
    April 8th, 2009

    There is a huge reason she didnt win!!!!!!

  4. dafeedil
    April 9th, 2009

    Yeah, I’ll agree, Kellie Pickler totally sucks. Anyways, I was SO hoping that the judges would have used their save on Scott. Sure, he sucks as a singer, but that would have taken away that save from the judges. So if Glambert or Danny Douchey to happen to get in the bottom, you know they’ll use that save on one of them. I really thought Lil was going home, but she’ll be next probably. All these freaking little teenie boppers think that Adam is so cute and so cool, has anyone out there google imaged him? He French kisses boys and dresses like a transvestite, and he looks pretty damned happy doing it. People say he does that just for the camera, come on, a straight man would NEVER do the crap that Glambert does, “just for the camera”. So, in the end it’s probably going to be that flaming mo as the winner. God, no wonder so many people in the world hate Americans, look at what this country produces, accepts and “idolizes”, people like him, ugggg.

  5. Adam
    April 9th, 2009

    SO what if I’m GAY!!! Get over it you douchebags.

  6. grumpyoldman
    April 9th, 2009

    Wow, Scott didn’t see that one coming….

  7. dafeedil
    April 9th, 2009

    Well, to Adam 1 post above. Just think, if you win, you can launch your own line of anal douchebags for men, and your pock-marked make-up wearing no-talent ugly ass face can be on the box. I don’t know, you can call it Massinglambert, the disposable douche for the undiscrimanating gay.

  8. Adam: Has Been or Never Was?
    April 9th, 2009

    No one gives a shit that adam is gay in a homosexual way. It’s the being gay in a “shitastic cats-in-heat singing voice, smug poseur who could have been any other musical theater douchebag” way. The pimping of this hack is ridiculous!

  9. jenny
    April 10th, 2009

    grumpyoldman….LOL that was REALLY,REALLY wrong….but oh soooo funny :) We are both going to hell

  10. ExcuseMe!
    April 10th, 2009

    Yes kellie sucked; but did u see her dress ? It was so pretty :) and to all you Adam haters, I’m a Adam fan 100% and does it matter of he’s gay or not. It’s America, get over it. He’s 1000000000 times better then any of you other ppl out there so shut it. And Scott , we all knew he wouldn’t win but ya know we need his humor in the show. I can’t stand watching lil rounds or anoop anymore. Scott is one of the reasons why I watch the show cause ya never know when he’s gonna start bouncing around on he stage. Well goodbye Scott, u made American idol fun:).

  11. BOOHOO
    April 13th, 2009

    LOL. People come in here and whine about the hate, but then spew their hate for this site… Pot meet kettle.

  12. grumpyoldman
    April 13th, 2009

    The real hateful people are the wardrobe and hair people at Idol….first they staple a poodle on Scott’s head, and then dress him like Bobby Sherman ala 1970. And he doesn’t have a clue.

  13. Adam's friend Royce
    April 13th, 2009

    Adam likes to have zucchinis shoved up his ass while I give him pickle washes. You people have a problem with that ? So what if he is gay ? He is trying to represent the American people.

  14. katie
    April 13th, 2009

    Are you all seriously hating on Adam? You all are messed up then. You keep mentioning that you all aren’t homophobic but yet I still see people saying stuff about how he’s gay and dresses like a transvestite. THIS IS A SINGING CONTEST. Who the hell cares if he’s gay? The girls sure dont. All the girls are in love with him! He’s got talent and is good looking. You are all just hating on him because you wish you had his voice and looks. Adam has made so many people smile when he is on for 3 minutes then you would ever make happy your whole life. Get a life people, there’s better things to do then bash Adam Lambert.

  15. anonymous
    April 13th, 2009

    Good job Katie! I agree with you 100%. And ironically,

  16. anonymous
    April 13th, 2009

    I share the same name as you!

  17. grumpyoldman
    April 14th, 2009

    What’ craterface singing tonight? If he does Phantom of the Opera, at least he can wear a mask on half his face.

  18. KickAdamsAss
    April 14th, 2009

    OK let’s clear up gay:

    NOBODY CARES if ADAM is GAY!

    HERE IS WHAT WE HATE, AND CAN’T BELIEVE

    PEOPLE ACTUALLY THINK HE CAN SING, AND REALLY BELIEVE HE IS A ROCK! US PEOPLE IN HERE KNOW THE TRUTH, HE SUCKS, HE CAN’T SING AND IDOL IS A JOKE! ADAM IS MORE OF A STAGE ACTOR, AND BELONGS IN OFF-OFF BROADWAY MUSICALS (REALLY OFF)

    AGAIN SO WHAT IF ADAM IS GAY, WHO CARES, WE DON’T! PEOPLE HE CAN’T SING (LISTEN HARDER)

  19. April 22nd, 2009

    hi this is adam lamberts biggest fan you guys can f*** off just bcuz ur haters doesnt meen u need to be assholes

  20. Smattles
    April 22nd, 2009

    To Sivanna: 2 BAD U R 2 YOUNG 2 USE PROPER ENGLISH SPELLING, PUNCTUATION, & GRAMMAR-DO “U” WRITE EXAMS LIKE THAT? If not, why wouldn’t you use a more intellectual way to write that very “impressive”, and “mature” post. Good luck with life! Glad you wrote “ur” heart on your sleeve!! LOL
    p.s I love your version of “Mean”!

  21. UDontNeed2KNOW
    April 24th, 2009

    Even if Adam is gay,Who the f**k cares! I don’t! Bsides he doesn’t look gay to me!

  22. Nunyabiz
    April 28th, 2009

    ok for the people who r posing as adam n whoevr else, thx 4 backing them up but change ur name cuz thts a little creepo

  23. Nunyabiz
    April 28th, 2009

    to the rest who r also supporting adam thx he rocks

  24. becky
    April 28th, 2009

    Nunyabiz…
    Please read Smattles post and apply it to your own.

  25. May 3rd, 2009

    i just want adam to win and every one else to be gone they are uselys

Post a Comment






Subscribe to the We Hate Idol RSS feed!

If you enjoy the content on this site and would like to help me pay the bills, please use the "donate" option below. Any amount is greatly appreciated.
Thank you! -Jill



We Hate Idol Footer