Episode Recaps, Season 8 »

MEGAN JOY CORKREY voted off American Idol

Published on: April 1, 2009 – 9:05 pm by Jillian Madison Comment

Megan, Anoop, and Allison were the bottom 3 performers, but Megan Joy was the one voted off American Idol on tonight’s episode. No more short sleeves and pee-pee dances – horray! BUH BYE, MEGAN.

ai31709-8



  1. Jennifer
    April 1st, 2009

    HOW WAS SCOTT NOT IN THE BOTTOM THREE?? Can someone please explain that to me? PLEASE? I beg you! Is he Vote For the Worst’s pick? How far can the pity vote carry him- or are there just that many Billy Joel fans out there? For the love, people, stop voting for this man!

  2. dafeedil
    April 1st, 2009

    Jennifer, I think Megan has been the VFTW favorite. I don’t get why Scott’s made it this far either, I really do think he gets a lot of sympathy votes. I would, however, rather watch 17 hours of his crappy singing than watch 3 seconds of Flaming Boy Glambert, that guy literally makes my stomach turn.

  3. Pete
    April 1st, 2009

    i wont miss that awful voice of hers. just awful.
    and add me to the lis of people hoping adam GLAMbert will be next.

  4. April 2nd, 2009

    You guys are all just upset because none of you are good enough to make it on American Idol or either that you went to audition for American Idol and you got REJECTED! YES REJECTED. Let me spell that out for you R-E-J-E-C-T-E-D. These people put there heart into something they believe they can do to try and make something of their life. All you guys do is sit on your (excuse me) god damn asses talking shit about other people because you can’t get up and do something with your life. Adam Lambert, he is a wonderful singer and originally when I heard that he was going to sing “Play That Funky Music (White Boy)” I was like “This is going to be bad” but in all actuality he did a great job, he sounded good doing it, even if he ‘mimicked’ another person’s rendition of it, he still sounded good. Scott, he is a great singer, and you guys always rag on him because he plays his keyboard when he sings. That doesn’t make him a bad singer, it means that he has intentions of playing his own music, not having someone do it for him like Britney Spears, Backstreets Boys, or some other corny ass pop group. Maybe Scott’s inspiration was Ray Charles. He was a blind singer/songwriter, but none of you guys rag on him. Scott actually has a really good voice. Why don’t you all get a life and quit ragging on the people who are doing something with their lives, something you can’t do!

  5. dafeedil
    April 2nd, 2009

    Sounds like someone who has enough free time to make such a lengthy and rambling post is the one who needs to get a life. Go to one of the fantard sites if this one bothers you so much.

  6. Chuckles the CEO
    April 2nd, 2009

    Oh A$$WIPE above, you must have recently been released from under a rock because you clearly have zero taste in music.

  7. Jennifer
    April 2nd, 2009

    Wow, we only got 4 comments in before we got the obligatory Idol Fan comment. Here, I’ll add my own:

    “You guys are all meany-heads! I bet you can’t sing as well as Megan, and so you’re jealous! Whoever makes up this site is a meany-head too! Stupid, stupid mean people! You should all DIE! Not like me, I’m a bleeding heart junior high student. Hope is my oxygen and merriment is my way of life. I would never be so mean… except when I tell you all that you should suck your grandmother’s c*ck and die! …But that’s the only time.”

  8. grumpyoldman
    April 2nd, 2009

    So sad this morning with my lovely Meghan sent home. Her voice was a precious gift from above, but she didn’t fit the three or four pre-made molds of who AI thinks a singer is.
    I was so glad to see her leave with a smile and a great attitude. And a caw for the VFTW’ers!!
    I will buy her music.
    As for Kara: S#ck it baby. If you want a drama queen for an Idol, you’ll get him. But what the heck is wrong with his face….in HD it’s really revolting.

  9. Jennifer
    April 2nd, 2009

    Oh, and please don’t ever, EVER compare Scott to Ray Charles again.

  10. April 2nd, 2009

    “Sounds like someone who has enough free time to make such a lengthy and rambling post is the one who needs to get a life. Go to one of the fantard sites if this one bothers you so much.”

    -One makes such a lengthy comment when they have read more than one blog on the same site so that they don’t have to go to each one separately and comment, it’s pointless to waste that much time. This one doesn’t bother me all that much, because I’m not the greatest fan of American Idol because I don’t believe it is the people’s vote. I think Fox or the producers of AI have set it up so when someone is getting the lowest ratings on the show they boot them out so they can keep their ratings up. Why the hell do you think they take so many people who can’t sing and let them get to Hollywood only to be humiliated by Simon.

    “Oh A$$WIPE above, you must have recently been released from under a rock because you clearly have zero taste in music.”

    - I have more taste in music than you probably will ever have. I know who can sing when I see it. I’ve been singing for years, and have had the chance to work with some wonderful vocal coaches who teach you a lot more than American Idol ever will. Some of the people on this show can sing, but apparently NONE of you have taste is music, because no one on this show is good enough for you guys.

    “Wow, we only got 4 comments in before we got the obligatory Idol Fan comment. Here, I’ll add my own:

    ‘You guys are all meany-heads! I bet you can’t sing as well as Megan, and so you’re jealous! Whoever makes up this site is a meany-head too! Stupid, stupid mean people! You should all DIE! Not like me, I’m a bleeding heart junior high student. Hope is my oxygen and merriment is my way of life. I would never be so mean… except when I tell you all that you should suck your grandmother’s c*ck and die! …But that’s the only time.’ ”

    - Like I stated earlier in this comment, I’m not the biggest fan of American Idol, I don’t feel it is based on the people. And Megan, good riddance, I didn’t like her, she could NOT sing whatsoever, so if you think I was thinking she should have been staying on the show, you are sadly mistaken. Oh, and I will compare who I want with whomever I want. Nobody said he was as good as Ray Charles, but he could have potential of being famous like Ray Charles. Scott does have a great voice, and the fact that he can play some instrument makes it that much better. I’d like to see you go blind and learn how to play the piano or the guitar. So |3itch STFU!

  11. trex
    April 2nd, 2009

    OH FUCK ALL OF YOU ASSHOLE IDOL HATERS! you fucking wanna be’s are just so jealous! Coz you guys are fucking retards!!!! I’LL SURELY MISS MEGAN, she’s really one of the most original contestants idol’s ever had! SO BEAT IT YOU MORONS and try to get a LIFE!

  12. Chuckles the CEO
  13. dafeedil
    April 2nd, 2009

    You can certainly tell when middle school gets out for the day.

  14. Lindsay
    April 2nd, 2009

    Wow, Megan was really unprofessional last night. From her scary-overly dramatic facial expressions, to her caw-caw-ing over to her seat in the bottom three, I was disappointed in the way she presented herself.

    Also, LOL at her telling Simon she didn’t care. Yeah, right. If you didn’t care, you wouldn’t have made it that far.

  15. Ricky
    April 2nd, 2009

    Sounds like UR ALL A$$HOLES is fucking Simon Cowell and apparently Adam Lambert as well. And obviously this idiot doesn’t have a life cuz he/she/it keeps commenting and bitching us all out. And TREX, sounds like you got your taste for music in some karakoe club. Either that or your defending her because she has a nice body and your…well… you know.

    And please do not compare Scott to Ray Charles. Thats like comparing Adam Lambert to Mick Jagger (Paula’s a dumbshit).

  16. Hailey
    April 3rd, 2009

    I love how just because Scott is blind musician, “UR ALL A$$HOLES” just assumes that his only possible inspiration is another blind musician. Maybe he loves Stevie Wonder and Ronnie Milsap too!!! Or maybe (just maybe), Scott was inspired by other musicians because of their talent and musicality, not because they shared a similar disability.

  17. April 4th, 2009

    Are the judges too blind not too see how ridiculous Scott looked that night?

  18. jenny
    April 5th, 2009

    Gerry LOL LOL……WTF is up with the way they are dressing the poor guy and doing his hair??? Just because he can’t see what he looks like doesn’t me they have to put him in pink pants. That is why he is getting sympathy votes, because everyone feels sorry for the Idol fashion guinea pig. They probably told him that the pants were khaki LOL

    To the 2 idiots defending the contestants, this site is called we hate idol, seriously WTF did you expect when you came to this site?????

  19. April 6th, 2009

    “I love how just because Scott is blind musician, “UR ALL A$$HOLES” just assumes that his only possible inspiration is another blind musician. Maybe he loves Stevie Wonder and Ronnie Milsap too!!! Or maybe (just maybe), Scott was inspired by other musicians because of their talent and musicality, not because they shared a similar disability.”

    You are a fuck-tard. Nobody obviously knows how to actually read anything. I wasn’t necessarily saying that he was looking at Ray Charles for inspiration, I was making a point that you guys rag on him because the fact that he IS blind. Why don’t you guys just STFU and let these people do what they enjoy doing. I’d like to see any one of you guys get your ass up on stage and sing in front of millions of people and then get almost always harshly criticized by some jackass judges. A lot of us know that, yes, some of them can’t sing, but why rag on someone so much for trying to make a living doing something that makes them happy. Have any of you ever made an attempt an attempt at making yourself happy? Hmm? I didn’t think so. I’m sure the majority of you sit at the computer reading what other people have to say and try to come up with something witty. I actually have a life, and I am doing something that makes me happy. What can you say for yourself? With that I bid y’all goodbye, and just have to say karma comes back around tenfold.

  20. jctrustme
    April 6th, 2009

    “I wasn’t necessarily saying that he was LOOKING at Ray Charles for inspiration”

    The dudes blind, have some respect asshole.

  21. grumpyoldman
    April 6th, 2009

    I am so sad for Scott, knowing that because of his lack of sight, he never knew just how gorgeous our Meghan is. Our how horrifically scarred Adam’s face is. Unless he tried to read his face like a book written in Braille.

Post a Comment






Subscribe to the We Hate Idol RSS feed!

If you enjoy the content on this site and would like to help me pay the bills, please use the "donate" option below. Any amount is greatly appreciated.
Thank you! -Jill



We Hate Idol Footer